In The Land Of FREE we still Keep on Rockin'

It's Not Dark Yet

Plain and Fancy

Music gives soul to universe, wings to mind, flight to imagination, charm to sadness, and life to everything.


Thursday, January 19, 2012

Egg - The Polite Force (1971 uk, significant progressive experimental rock, 2008 esoteric remaster)

Egg perfected their distinctive, organ-driven prog with their second and best album. Stewart's excellent playing varied between his light organ-tone and to the more typical, heavy distorted Canterbury sound. The opening track "A Visit to Newport Hospital" demonstrates this perfect.

Light and jazzier playing in some wonderful atmospheric themes relieve VERY heavy organ in other parts. "Contrasong" is a track that features some horns and is complex in a kind of Gentle Giant way. Then comes the really tragic thing about this otherwise superb album: 9 minutes of completely pointless noise and sound effects in "Boilk". If these 9 minutes instead had been filled up with a track of the same quality as the rest of the album, then "The Polite Force" would have been one of the true keyboard-progressive rock classics of the 70's, in league with "Brain Salad Surgery" and "Spartacus".

Fortunately, the second side of the album consists of the great, 20-minute suite "Long Piece No.3" and was probably the best thing Egg ever recorded. Incredibly complex and one of the best pieces of music ever performed on just organ, drums and bass! If you forget about the idiotic "Boilk" then this IS still a great album and worth whatever you have to pay for it. Fans of organ-driven progressive rock with a perfect 70's atmosphere will eat it up.

1. A Visit to Newport Hospital (Campbell) - 8:28
2. Contrasong (Campbell) - 4:25
3. Boilk (Brown, Campbell, Stewart) - 9:22
4. Long Piece No. 3 - 5:08
5. Long Piece No. 3 (Continued) - 7:38
6. Long Piece No. 3 (Continued) - 5:03
7. Long Piece No. 3 (Continued) - 2:51
All songs by Brooks, Campbell, Stewart except where indicated.

*Clive Brooks - Drums, Vocals
*Dave Stewart - Organ, Piano
*Mont Campbell - Bass, Vocals
Guest Musicians
*Mike Davis - Trumpet
*Bob Downes - Sax (Tenor), Saxophone
*Henry Lowther - Trumpet
*Stephen Solloway - Flute
*Tony Roberts - Tenor Sax

Free Text


  1. Great stuff, Marios. A prog keyboard trio with a sound totally different from the others--ELP, Rare Bird, Quatermass, etc.

    Btw, a definitive vinyl rip recently posted on Avax for those interested.

  2. Meant to say I linked that in the chatbox.

  3. @DanP thanks for that link to avax, nice rip and thanks Marios for c.d rip.Top band!

  4. Marios,

    Two Bonus Tracks for Album:

    8) A Visit to Newport Hospital (Edit Version)

    9) Long Piece no.3 - Part. 2 (Edit Version)

    Password: IVO



  5. ...The Polite...reForce.....

  6. Thank you for the remaster, Marios!

  7. This is a tremendous record, and unlike the reviewer, I think Boilk is great.

    It's like Revolution 9.

    Thank you for sharing this Marios.


    Sunday 15th February 2015 8.18pm GMT

  8. Would it be possible to restore the link for this EGG - The Polite Force CD? Thank you.

  9. GB, "Egg - The Polite Force". reloaded...

  10. Thanks for the Egg, a great album. As for the review, yeah yeah yeah, Boilk just ruined this album, just like Revolution 9 made The White Album suck, right? Sheesh! Ya don't HAVE to listen to it if you hate it that much. I like both tracks just fine. They may both excel in clearing the room, but that works for me too!